7+ Best Toasters of 2019

Whether you are a seasoned home chef or a college student, you should always have the best toaster on your counter top. Toasters have come a long way in the past few years from 2 and 4 slot pop up toasters to hilarious novelty toasters to toasters that cook hot dogs.

We’ve done our research and compiled a list of our favorite toasters.

thickandtired.co toaster buyer's guide

Types Of Toasters

When it comes to buying a new toaster, one of the first things you will notice is that your options are somewhat limited when it comes to selecting a specific type of toaster that you would like. While there are many brands out there manufacturing these convenient products, there really are just three broad categories of toasters that you are able to choose from.

The three categories we are referring to would include:

  • Two-slice toasters
  • Four-slice toasters
  • Novelty toasters

While this may seem inconvenient to some when considering the various categories that are often included when looking at other appliances you would usually use in your kitchen, the fact that there are only three broad categories of toasters on the market helps to simplify things for you.

When there is a significant variety of products on the market, it becomes much more difficult to determine which type would best suit your needs. 

There are, however, a couple of toasters on the market that comes with some added convenient features. For example, some of the toasters we have seen features a bagel setting. While not everyone will require this particular feature, it can certainly be a convenience when it comes to toasting bagels – or when you simply wish to toast a single side of your bread. 

There is also a category of toasters that include additional “slots,” as they are often referred to, for food items that are shaped differently than your average slice of bread. This category of these products is becoming very popular lately and often allows you to easily toast your hot dog buns or even give you the ability to heat up hot dogs. This can be a truly unique and convenient feature that can make your life easier when it comes to preparing quick and easy lunches for the family. 


Best Two Slice Toasters

[amazon box=”B00140SC64″ /]


Cuisinart CPT-160 2-Slice Toaster

Cuisinart CPT-160 Toaster

Cuisinart CPT-160 features:

  • Beautiful stainless housing with polished chrome and black accents
  • 6-setting browning dial, reheat, defrost and bagel buttons
  • 1-1/2 in. wide toasting slots
  • Extra-lift carriage lever
  • Tidy cord wrap
  • Slide-out crumb tray
  • Instruction manual included
  • BPA free


KitchenAid KMT2116CU 2 Slice Toaster

KitchenAid KMT2116CU

KitchenAid KMT2116CU features:

  • 2-slice toaster with all metal construction
  • Extra-wide 1 1/2″ slots
  • Bagel button with toasting on one side
  • 5-shade setting
  • Cancel button
  • Chrome buttons with blue back-light illumination when in use
  • Manual high-lift lever
  • Removable crumb tray
  • Under base cord storage

Best Four Slice Toasters

Breville BTA830XL 4-Slice Long Slot Smart Toaster

Breville BTA830XL Toaster

Breville BTA830XL features:

  • Self-centering, long slots accommodate artisan breads or up to 4 standard slices
  • Fully motorized one touch “Lift & Look” button to check progress
  • “A Bit More”” button for a little extra toast time
  • 1 Touch buttons for bagels, frozen and cancelling
  • 1 Year Warranty


Cuisinart CPT-180 4-Slice Toaster

Cuisinart CPT-180 Toaster

Cuisinart CPT-180 features:

  • Separate control panels
  • Stainless housing with chrome and black accents
  • Two 6-setting toasting dials, dual reheat, defrost and bagel buttons
  • 1 1⁄2″ – wide toasting slots
  • Extra-lift carriage lever
  • Crumb tray
  • Limited 3-year warranty
  • BPA Free


Black+Decker TR4310FBD 4-Slice Extra-Wide Slot Toaster

Black+Decker TR4310FBD

Black+Decker TR4310FBD features:

  • Shade Selector
  • Extra-Wide Slots
  • Extra Lift
  • Self-Centering Guides
  • One-Touch Buttons
  • Swing-Down Crumb Tray

Best Star Wars Toasters

Pangea Brands Darth Vader Star Wars Toaster

Darth Vader Star Wars Toaster

Darth Vader Toaster features:

  • Darth Vader on toast!
  • Compact Two-Slice Toaster with Cool-Touch Housing.
  • Reheat, Defrost, and Quick Stop Functions
  • Adjustable Thermostat
  • Automatic/Manual Switch-Off
  • Removable Crumb Tray
  • Officially Licensed

Best Hot Dog Toasters

Nostalgia Retro Pop-Up Hot Dog Toaster

Best Hot Dog Toaster

Hot Dog Toaster features:

  • Cooks two delicious regular-size or extra-plump hot dogs at a time
  • Two buns at a time
  • Adjustable cooking timer and stop cooking button
  • Removable hot dog cage
  • Mini tongs for removing hot dogs
  • Drip tray for easy cleaning

What To Look For When Buying A Toaster

Buying a toaster may seem like a fairly simple task. This is a very basic device that simply serves the purpose of toasting your bread. This is the thought that many people would have when they decide to buy a new toaster for their kitchen. Unfortunately, once you hit the stores or start browsing for a toaster online, you quickly notice that there are simply too many toasters to choose from. 

Choose the wrong toaster, and you might end up with a product that will not heat your toast evenly or perhaps you will have to become satisfied with burnt toast due to excessive heating. It is crucial that you buy the right toaster that can do the job – but also satisfy your particular preferences and requirements when it comes to toasting bread, bagels, and perhaps even hot dog buns. 

Let’s consider a couple of factors that you should always try to keep in mind when you set out on a journey to find the perfect toaster to add to your kitchen. 

Toaster Size

We would recommend you start by considering the ideal toaster size you would prefer. These products generally come in two-slice and four-slice options. If you are going to need to toast a larger number of slices to prepare lunch for the family, then you might want to consider opting for a four-slice toaster. While a four-slice toaster might be a little more expensive than a two-slice option, it can save you a lot of time. 

At the same time, while considering whether a two-slice or four-slice toaster may be the most ideal option for you, you should take into consideration the available size on your kitchen counter. If you opt for a four-slice toaster, it will be larger than the average two-slice option. This means the toaster will take up more space on your counter – if there isn’t enough space available, then it might be a good idea to rather opt for a smaller two-slice toaster. This can help to save some space. 

Cost Of The Toaster

You should also consider the cost of the toaster that you might be considering into account. Even though a toaster may seem like such a basic device, these products can sometimes be expensive. You will need to know how much money you are able to spend on a toaster before you set out to find one – this will be of tremendous help. If you know your budget, you can filter through the toasters that are available only to include those that fit within your budget. 

Added Features

As noted previously, not all toasters on the market today are the same. Companies are becoming competitive and making toasters that come with added features to make the use of the product more convenient than ever before. 

There are numerous features that you might want to look out for in order to make sure that the toaster you end up buying can be as convenient as possible in your kitchen. Here’s a quick overview of some possible features that you might want to look for:

  • A bagel setting allows you to fit a bagel on the top of the toaster. This is great for those who love eating bagels, as well as people who would like to toast a single side of their bread slice. 
  • The addition of a crumb tray can also be beneficial, as this provides an area for crumbs to collect and makes it much easier to clean up, as well as to avoid messes. 
  • A defrost setting can also be useful for people who are used to freezing their bread. 

Best Ways to Use Your Toaster

When you think of a toaster, you obviously think about toasted bread. This is the primary reason why people tend to buy a toaster. They wish to toast bread – this makes a great addition to a breakfast that includes bacon and eggs, perhaps. Toast also makes a quick and easy snack – simply add some toppings or a spread, and you are good to go. These are not the only reasons why people are buying toasters in recent days. 

Toasters can also be used to toast other items – bagels would definitely be the most popular alternative, as we have previously noted. Not all toasters can toast bagels, however. Thus, if you are looking to toast your bagels with this particular product, then you should ensure the particular toaster you buy has a bagel setting. 

Some toasters can be used as a device for defrosting frozen bread as well. This is not the most common setting in toasters, but an increasing number of toasters do come out with a defrost setting. If you are keen on keeping a few frozen breads in the freezer, then this can be a great feature for you. 


Advantages Of Owning A Toaster

A toaster is certainly a very convenient appliance to have in the kitchen. While the use of a toaster is mostly associated with toasting a few slices of bread, there are many other ways that a toaster can be used – providing you with a number of additional benefits, apart from being able to pop a few slices of bread into the toaster. 

Let’s assume you are dropping the kids off from school, but you do not have much time to spend with them before you need to be back at the office. The kids will likely be hungry – cooking up an entire meal can take up too much time, and you cannot afford to be late to work. 

In this type of scenario, a toaster can become exceptionally useful. Toast gives kids a great alternative to a normal slice of bread and goes well with a number of different spreads. 

You can also add a bagel to the top if your toaster has the appropriate function to support a bagel. This is another great option for grabbing a quick bite when you are on-the-go, or for preparing something different for the kids to enjoy when you have to go back to work. 

Since there are a variety of toaster types on the market as well, with some of them providing better and more advanced features than others, it is important to note that each toaster may have a set of advantages associated with it. 

For example, when the toaster has a crumb tray built in, there is no need to worry about crumbs collecting on the bottom of the toaster – you’ll be able to remove the tray and clean it out before adding a new batch of bread to the toaster. A crumb tray also helps to avoid the risk of making a mess in the kitchen when you are dealing with toast, yet another added benefit that should certainly be taken into consideration. 

There are some toasters with a built-in defrost setting as well. While not everyone tends to freeze their bread, some people to prefer to buy in bulk and keep some extra bread in the freezer. In this case, you would first need to have the bread defrosted before you can use it. If the toast you buy has a defrost setting, you can easily pop in the frozen slice of bread and switch on the defrost feature. The toaster will quickly defrost the bread – you can then choose to have it toasted as well. 

7+ Best Toasters of 2019